Creepy Punch | Shelter Insurance®

What’s That in the Punch Bowl?

Here’s a fun, creepy recipe guaranteed to delight people at your Halloween party.


1 (.13 ounce) packet unsweetened grape drink powder

1 (.13 ounce) packet unsweetened orange drink powder

2 cups white sugar

3 quarts cold water

1 liter ginger ale


  1. Mix first four ingredients together.
  2. Add ginger ale just before serving.

Now, for an extra-creepy touch, float a frozen hand in the bowl. Wash out a disposable plastic glove; fill it with water; seal with a rubber band; and put it in the freezer. When you’re ready to serve the punch, briefly submerge the glove in warm water. The frozen hand will slide out. Then float the hand in the punch bowl for a ghoulish effect.