contact us1-800-SHELTER

Your Insurance Premium Payment Options

Choose How to Pay:

Pay by cash, check, debit/credit card, money order

Choose Where to Pay:

By Visiting your Agent

Agent Cash Check Use your debit/credit card to make payments on your policy Money order


Your local agent can accept all payment options in their office. Talk to your agent about setting up automatic monthly withdrawals from your checking account.

By Mailing

Mail Check Money order

Mail checks or money orders directly to our home office:

Shelter Insurance
1817 W Broadway
Columbia, MO 65218

By Calling


Check Use your debit/credit card to make payments on your policy

Our Customer Service Representatives accept payments from 6 a.m. to midnight CST. You can pay using most major debit or credit cards. You can also set up automatic monthly withdrawals from your checking account.

1-800-SHELTER (743-5837)

By Logging in


CheckMake your next premium payment using your My Shelter Account to pay with your debit/credit card.

With a My Shelter account, you can pay your bills online by using a credit or debit card or a checking account. You can also reduce mail we send you, print proof of insurance, and more. Log in or register for a My Shelter account.

Choose When to Pay:

Are you someone who gets overwhelmed keeping track of monthly due dates? If so, or if you have multiple policies coming due at the same time, you can use one of the following options to spread out your payment deadlines:

We offer policy term date options to help meet your financial needs.

  • Monthly automatic withdrawals from your checking account (12 payments per year)
  • Semi-annual (2 payments per year)
  • Annual (1 payment per year)

These options can be adjusted by your agent or a Customer Service Representative. They can help you decide which option best fits your needs.


Back to Top